Ministers who have served the congregation are:
| Rev. John McDowell | 1858-18– |
| Rev. A. Brown | |
| Rev. Stevenson | |
| Mr. McKinley, student | 1862 – 18– |
| Rev. J.F. McLaren, D.D. | 1879 – 1913 |
| Rev. R.W. Beveredge | 1913 – 1915 |
| Rev. W.M. Lee, M.A. | 1915 – 1919 |
| Rev. John Lennox | 1919 – 1924 |
| Rev. T.E. Kennedy | 1924 – 1925 |
| Dr. John MacDougall, D.D. | 1926 – 1929 |
| John R. Wilkinson | 1929 – 1934 |
| Rev. S. Scott Milley | 1934 – 1936 |
| Rev. Arthur A. Jenner | 1936 – 1940 |
| Rev. E.V. Warren | 1940 – 1945 |
| Rev. S.E. Hayward | 1945 – 1947 |
| Rev. Herbert Bandy | 1947 – 1949 |
| Rev. Cyril R. Leach | 1949 – 1951 |
| Rev. J.R. Dickenson | 1951 – 1952 |
| Dalton C. Blackmore (ordained /55) | 1952 – 1955 |
| Allan Shaw (ordained /58) | 1955 – 1958 |
| Donald E. Inkpen | 1958 – 1959 |
| Rev. John Hayward | 1959 – 1962 |
| Ivan H. Cook | 1962 – 1963 |
| Rev. Edward Ronayne | 1963 – 1965 |
| Kenneth Tanner (ordained /72 at Temple Hill) | 1965 – 1973 |
| Rev. Hope Jackson | 1973 – 1977 |
| Rev. E. Milroy | 1977 – 1981 |
| Rev. E. Tudor Jones | 1981 – 1983 |
| Laurie McKnight-Walker, B.A. Dip. Ch. Ed. M. Ed. | 1983 – 1988 |
| Victor Poelzer (ordained /89) | 1988 – 1990 |
| Rev. George McPhee | 1991 – 1992 |
| Marilyn Leuty (ordained May 1994) | 1992 – 2000 |
| Rev. Cora Krommenhoek (ordained at Temple Hill) | 2000 – 2001 |
| Sylvia Bell (interim minister) | 2001 – 2002 |
| Rosanne Judge (Lay Pastoral Minister) | 2003 – 2011 |
| Michael Henkel, B.A. (Lay Worship Leader) | 2010 – 2017 |
| Rev. Neil Parker, D.D. (interim minister) | 2018 – 2021 |
| Rev. Rebekah Duncan, Minister 2021 – present |